Clan Pros and Cons

[GRIM ||]

This is the game where you post all your pros and cons about the four clans in the forest. For example, this is mine.


PROS
ThunderClan- Good, loyal warriors who follow the warrior code. That is the definition of being a warrior, yes?
WindClan- Loyal, fiercely protective, and the underdogs. They are speedy and really amazing.

CONS
RiverClan- Smug and way too self centered. Having the river doesn't make them better than anyone else. o_0
ShadowClan- They eat frogs, and are greedy. Enough said. :3



Pros are the ones you like. And cons are the ones you dislike. It'd be funner to post an information sentence or two about why. This can be a debate thread. ;]

[Mewey]

PROS

ThunderClan

Honesty and character seem to be valued in this Clan; even when things do go wrong, like LeafpoolxCrowheart's little love affair, ThunderClan cats seem to always (eventually) fall back to the truth and own up to the consequences.

ShadowClan

Loyalty seems to run deep here. (Maybe discounting the little blip with Brokenstar-- but that tom was loony. o_o) What ShadowClan warrior hasn't made his high opinions of his Clan very clear in the series? Most of the warriors appear to be proud and true to their Clan, even if they don't go about showing it in the nicest way, and Blackstar undoubtedly takes his position as leader with modesty and consideration. Even when he tried to move his Clan away from StarClan, he was always looking at the best intentions for his Clan. And when it comes to fighting-- well, Hunter has always described any ShadowClan battle scenes with heart, skill, and persistence. They've always been a major player in any war, definitely not the underdog. You have to admire this Clan, even if you do so grudgingly because you think they're rude or so. :D

WindClan

I have kind of mixed feelings about this Clan. I'm not sure where this sudden, rugged power surge of their's came from, but they definitely are proving to finally be able to hold their own among the other Clans. But I do like this newfound determination and proud loyalty to their Clan, like Grim stated.

NEUTRAL

RiverClan

Kind of an unremarkable Clan so far, mediocre in warriors, skills, and warfare. I know they like knowing how to swim and all, but what does that really do for them? Oh, good job RiverClan, you have another way to escape when you're all high-tailing it out of your camp because ShadowClan invaded amd you couldn't take the heat. (Because, you know, just running away on plain ground isn't good enough... :/) They don't even stick to the warrior code very well, from what I've seen. (SilvexGray, anyone? I wouldn't have accepted Graystripe into my Clan after he knocked up my daughter...) So yeah. Neutral, I suppose...

CONS

ThunderClan

Too noble, too perfect. I realize this is probably just the Erins' portrayal of them, but it's also something I can't really look past. Does ThunderClan always have to save the day? Do they always have to make it out okay? A little suffrage, or greed, or something would satisfy me.

ShadowClan

They are kind of rude about things, and quick to battle. (But that's because they CAN.) If you haven't already figured it out, I like ShadowClan.^^ But I'll try not to be too biased...

WindClan

They're kind of weak; sorry, but they are. Skinny and small cats- typical WindClan build- just aren't going to stand up well against solid tree-climbers of ThunderClan, or the well-muscled swimmers of RiverClan. They just have a physical disadvantage. I think if they developed a trait that would make up for this disadvantage (particular cunning, maybe?) I could have a bit more respect for them. Exceptional speed just doesn't cut it when fighting in close quarters, though. :/ And other than agility, the only WindClan exclusive I see is a seemingly-overnight bad temper.

So yeahs... that's my take so far.^^
Change my opinion! :P